CMR FigSearch
Home Help [Feedback] [For Subscribers] [Archive] [Search] [Contents]
This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowReprints and Permissions
Right arrow Copyright Information
Right arrow Books from ASM Press
Right arrow MicrobeWorld
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Vázquez-Boland, J. A.
Right arrow Articles by Kreft, J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by Vázquez-Boland, J. A.
Right arrow Articles by Kreft, J.

 Previous Article  |  Next Article 

Clinical Microbiology Reviews, July 2001, p. 584-640, Vol. 14, No. 3
0893-8512/01/$04.00+0   DOI: 10.1128/CMR.14.3.584-640.2001
Copyright © 2001, American Society for Microbiology. All rights reserved.

Listeria Pathogenesis and Molecular Virulence Determinants

José A. Vázquez-Boland,1,2,* Michael Kuhn,3 Patrick Berche,4 Trinad Chakraborty,5 Gustavo Domínguez-Bernal,1 Werner Goebel,3 Bruno González-Zorn,1 Jürgen Wehland,6 and Jürgen Kreft3

Grupo de Patogénesis Molecular Bacteriana, Facultad de Veterinaria, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid,1 and Universidad de León, León,2 Spain; Unité INSERM U411, Faculté de Médecine Necker, 75730 Paris, France4; and Lehrstuhl für Mikrobiologie, Theodor-Boveri-Institut für Biowissenschaften der Universität Würzburg, 97074 Würzburg,3 Institut für Medizinische Mikrobiologie, Justus-Liebig-Universität, 35392 Giessen,5 and Department of Cell Biology and Immunology, Gesellschaft für Biotechnologische Forschung (GBF), 38124 Braunschweig,6 Germany

SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF LISTERIA INFECTION
    Clinical Features
        Fetomaternal and neonatal listeriosis.
        Listeriosis in adults.
    Pathogenesis
        Pathogenicity of L. monocytogenes.
        Host risk factors.
        Entry and colonization of host tissues.
        (i) Crossing the intestinal barrier.
        (ii) Multiplication in the liver.
        (iii) Colonization of gravid uterus and fetus.
        (iv) Invasion of the brain.
        Hypothetical scenario.
INTRACELLULAR INFECTIOUS CYCLE
    Internalization
    Intracellular Proliferation and Intercellular Spread
VIRULENCE FACTORS
    Hemolysin
        Characterization and role in escape from phagosome.
        Structure-function.
        Other roles in infection.
    Phospholipases
        Characterization.
        Role in virulence.
    ActA
    Internalins
    Other Virulence Factors
        p60 (iap).
        Antioxidant factors.
        Metal ion uptake.
        Stress response mediators.
GENETIC ORGANIZATION AND EVOLUTION OF VIRULENCE DETERMINANTS
    Central Virulencee Gene Cluster
    Internalin Islands
REGULATION OF VIRULENCE GENE EXPRESSION
    PrfA, Master Regulator of Virulence
    Environmental Control of Virulence Gene Expression
    Carbon Source Regulation of Virulence Genes
    Regulatory Mechanism of PrfA
    Fine Regulation of Virulence Determinants
HOST CELL RESPONSES TO INFECTION
    Signal Transduction Pathways Associated with Epithelial Cell Invasion
    Activation of NF-kappa B and Modulation of Host Gene Expression in Macrophages
    Host Responses during Infection of Endothelial Cells
    Apoptosis
CONCLUDING REMARKS AND FUTURE PERSPECTIVES
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
REFERENCES


SUMMARY
Top
Next
References

The gram-positive bacterium Listeria monocytogenes is the causative agent of listeriosis, a highly fatal opportunistic foodborne infection. Pregnant women, neonates, the elderly, and debilitated or immunocompromised patients in general are predominantly affected, although the disease can also develop in normal individuals. Clinical manifestations of invasive listeriosis are usually severe and include abortion, sepsis, and meningoencephalitis. Listeriosis can also manifest as a febrile gastroenteritis syndrome. In addition to humans, L. monocytogenes affects many vertebrate species, including birds. Listeria ivanovii, a second pathogenic species of the genus, is specific for ruminants. Our current view of the pathophysiology of listeriosis derives largely from studies with the mouse infection model. Pathogenic listeriae enter the host primarily through the intestine. The liver is thought to be their first target organ after intestinal translocation. In the liver, listeriae actively multiply until the infection is controlled by a cell-mediated immune response. This initial, subclinical step of listeriosis is thought to be common due to the frequent presence of pathogenic L. monocytogenes in food. In normal indivuals, the continual exposure to listerial antigens probably contributes to the maintenance of anti-Listeria memory T cells. However, in debilitated and immunocompromised patients, the unrestricted proliferation of listeriae in the liver may result in prolonged low-level bacteremia, leading to invasion of the preferred secondary target organs (the brain and the gravid uterus) and to overt clinical disease. L. monocytogenes and L. ivanovii are facultative intracellular parasites able to survive in macrophages and to invade a variety of normally nonphagocytic cells, such as epithelial cells, hepatocytes, and endothelial cells. In all these cell types, pathogenic listeriae go through an intracellular life cycle involving early escape from the phagocytic vacuole, rapid intracytoplasmic multiplication, bacterially induced actin-based motility, and direct spread to neighboring cells, in which they reinitiate the cycle. In this way, listeriae disseminate in host tissues sheltered from the humoral arm of the immune system. Over the last 15 years, a number of virulence factors involved in key steps of this intracellular life cycle have been identified. This review describes in detail the molecular determinants of Listeria virulence and their mechanism of action and summarizes the current knowledge on the pathophysiology of listeriosis and the cell biology and host cell responses to Listeria infection. This article provides an updated perspective of the development of our understanding of Listeria pathogenesis from the first molecular genetic analyses of virulence mechanisms reported in 1985 until the start of the genomic era of Listeria research.


INTRODUCTION
Top
Previous
Next
References

The genus Listeria consists of a group of gram-positive bacteria of low G+C content closely related to Bacillus, Clostridium, Enterococcus, Streptococcus, and Staphylococcus. Listeria spp. are facultative anaerobic rods of 0.4 by 1 to 1.5 µm that do not form spores, have no capsule, and are motile at 10 to 25°C (98, 552, 579). Listeria spp. are isolated from a diversity of environmental sources, including soil, water, effluents, a large variety of foods, and the feces of humans and animals. The natural habitat of these bacteria is thought to be decomposing plant matter, in which they live as saprophytes. Domesticated ruminants probably play a key role in the maintenance of Listeria spp. in the rural environment via a continuous fecal-oral enrichment cycle (178, 318, 420, 559, 682, 687, 692). The genus Listeria currently includes six species: L. monocytogenes, L. ivanovii, L. seeligeri, L. innocua, L. welshimeri, and L. grayi. Two of these species, L. monocytogenes and L. ivanovii, are potentially pathogenic. The infectious disease caused by these bacteria is known as listeriosis. L. monocytogenes causes serious localized and generalized infections in humans and a variety of other vertebrates, including domesticated and wild birds and mammals. The official discovery of Listeria microorganisms dates back to 1924, when E. G. D. Murray, R. A. Webb, and M. B. R. Swann isolated L. monocytogenes as the etiological agent of a septicemic disease affecting rabbits and guinea pigs in their laboratory at Cambridge in England (458). The first cases of human listeriosis were reported in 1929 in Denmark (481). However, the first recorded culture of L. monocytogenes dates from 1921, with the bacterium isolated in France by Dumont and Cotoni from a patient with meningitis (159, 604). L. ivanovii (formerly known as L. monocytogenes serotype 5) was first isolated in Bulgaria in 1955 from lambs with congenital listeriosis (299). Human cases of L. ivanovii infection are rare (116), the vast majority of reported isolations of this species being from abortions, stillbirths, and neonatal septicemias in sheep and cattle (4, 90, 134, 529, 610, 693). A third species, L. seeligeri, is considered nonpathogenic (555), although it has been implicated in at least one case of human listeriosis (556).

For many years, clinical Listeria isolates were a mere laboratory rarity, and the epidemiology of the disease was an unresolved mystery (603, 604). However, at the end of the 1970s and the start of the 1980s, the number of reports on Listeria isolations begun to increase, and from 1983 onwards, a series of epidemic outbreaks in humans in North America and Europe clearly established listeriosis as an important food-borne infection (46, 180, 386, 421, 572). The foods most frequently implicated are soft cheeses and dairy products, pâtés and sausages, smoked fish, salads, "delicatessen," and in general industrially produced, refrigerated ready-to-eat products that are eaten without cooking or reheating (176, 425-427, 551, 572). In ruminants, Listeria infection is transmitted by consumption of spoiled silage, in which these bacteria multiply readily, resulting in herd outbreaks (178, 666, 671, 693). Listeria organisms are widely disseminated in the rural environment and, consequently, contaminate the raw materials used in the preparation of industrially processed foods and the production plants as well (237). These bacteria are well equipped to survive food-processing technologies. For example, they tolerate high concentrations of salt and relatively low pHs, and worst of all, they are able to multiply at refrigeration temperatures (145, 362, 393, 426). This makes Listeria microorganisms a serious threat to food safety and ranks them among the microorganisms that most concern the food industry.

Researchers in immunology were interested in L. monocytogenes long before its importance as a risk to public health and food safety was recognized, because an infection highly reminiscent of human listeriosis was easily reproducible in laboratory rodents and protection could be transferred in syngeneic mice through spleen cells. Since the pioneering work of Mackaness in the early 1960s, which demonstrated that L. monocytogenes is able to survive and multiply in macrophages, this bacterium has been used in immunological research as a prototype intracellular parasite (401). For decades, the experimental model of Listeria infection in the mouse has made a significant contribution to our understanding of the cellular immune response (615). For example, key concepts such as the inability of antibodies to protect against infections produced by intracellular pathogens, the importance of activated macrophages in the elimination of intracellular parasites, and that the T cell is the macrophage-activating element required for cell-mediated immunity were established based on studies with the murine model of listeriosis (405, 406, 443, 478, 479).

In addition to the emergence of L. monocytogenes as a major food-borne pathogen, the 1980s also marked the start of investigations into the molecular mechanisms underlying Listeria virulence. The attention of researchers was first drawn to hemolytic activity, classically considered a virulence marker because it was present in the pathogenic species but not (with the exception of L. seeligeri) in the nonpathogenic species. These studies led between 1986 and 1989 to the discovery of the hemolysin gene, hly, and to elucidation of the key role that hemolysin plays in escape from destruction inside phagosomes, a prerequisite for intracellular bacterial proliferation. So, a decade ago, hemolysin became not only the first Listeria virulence factor to have its gene characterized, but also the first bacterial gene product to which a function critical to the survival of a parasite within the cells of the eukaryote host was attributed.

L. monocytogenes has since become not only an important paradigm for immunological investigation but also an important model system for analysis of the molecular mechanisms of intracellular parasitism (107). The identification of the hly gene was rapidly followed by a succession of discoveries resulting in complete characterization of the genetic locus to which this gene maps. This locus is a 9-kb virulence gene cluster that is involved in functions essential to intracellular survival. The internalin locus, inlAB, was also identified and characterized at this time (193). This locus encodes the first invasin described in a gram-positive bacterium, implicated in internalization by cells that are not usually phagocytic, such as epithelial and endothelial cells and hepatocytes. The progress made in the molecular characterization of listerial virulence factors during this period was summarized in a minireview published in 1992 (517). Many advances have since been made that have significantly increased our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of Listeria intracellular parasitism. The sequencing of the genomes of L. monocytogenes and L. innocua is currently finished (European Listeria Genome Consortium, unpublished data), with the expected outcome that very soon the panorama of research into the molecular pathogenesis of Listeria spp. will change dramatically.

The aim of this article is to review the knowledge gathered during the pregenomic era of Listeria research about the pathogenesis of listeriosis and the molecular virulence determinants involved. Readers interested more specifically in immunopathogenesis and the immune response should consult reference 497a. Those interested in issues related to taxonomy, clinical diagnosis and disease management, molecular typing, epidemiology, ecology, and food safety are also referred to other publications (145, 176, 289, 395, 550, 551, 573, 594, 605). For a historical perspective on Listeria spp. and listeriosis, we recommend the book Listeriosis by the pioneer listeriologist Heinz P. R. Seeliger (602) and the classical review, "Listeria monocytogenes and listeric infections," by Gray and Killinger (238).


PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF LISTERIA INFECTION
Top
Previous
Next
References

Clinical Features

The clinical signs of L. monocytogenes infection are very similar in all susceptible hosts. Two basic forms of presentation can be distinguished: perinatal listeriosis and listeriosis in the adult patient. In both instances, the predominant clinical forms correspond to disseminated infection or to local infection in the central nervous system (CNS). Listeriosis is usually a very severe disease---in fact, one of the most deadly bacterial infections currently known---with a mean mortality rate in humans of 20 to 30% or higher despite early antibiotic treatment (422, 423, 554, 594).

Fetomaternal and neonatal listeriosis. This form of presentation mainly results from invasion of the fetus via the placenta and develops as chorioamnionitis. Its consequence is abortion, usually from 5 months of gestation onwards, or the birth of a baby or stillborn fetus with generalized infection, a clinical syndrome known as granulomatosis infantiseptica and characterized by the presence of pyogranulomatous microabscesses disseminated over the body and a high mortality (336a) (Fig. 1). The infection is usually asymptomatic in the mother or may present as a mild flu-like syndrome with chills, fatigue, headache, and muscular and joint pain about 2 to 14 days before miscarriage. Less frequently (10 to 15% of perinatal cases), late neonatal listeriosis is observed. It generally occurs 1 to 8 weeks postpartum and involves a febrile syndrome accompanied by meningitis and, in some cases, gastroenteritis and pneumonia. It presumably results from aspiration of contaminated maternal exudates during delivery, although hospital-acquired cases involving horizontal transmission by fomites or medical personnel in neonatal units have been reported (177, 554, 628). The mortality of late-onset neonatal listeriosis is lower (10 to 20%), but like early-onset neonatal listeriosis, it may have sequelae such as hydrocephalus or psychomotor retardation (173). L. monocytogenes is one of the three principal causes of bacterial meningitis in neonates (391, 554, 594, 645).


View larger version (91K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIG. 1.   Clinical and pathological characteristics of Listeria infection in animals and humans. (A to D) Neuromeningeal listeriosis in sheep. (A) Typical aspect of circling disease, first described by Gill in 1933 in New Zealand (215, 216) and the most characteristic clinical manifestation of listeriosis in ruminants; the syndrome is characterized by involuntary torticollis and walking aimlessly in circles as a result of brainstem lesions. (B) In a further step of the infectious process, animals lie on the ground with evident signs of uncoordination (paddling movements) and cranial nerve paralysis (strabismus, salivation, etc.). (C) Section of the medulla oblongata of a sheep with listerial rhombencephalitis, showing clear inflammatory lesions in the brain tissue. (D) Microscopic preparation of the brainstem showing extensive parenchymal inflammatory infiltration and typical perivascular cuffing (one is indicated by an arrowhead) (panels C and D copyright M. Domingo, Barcelona, Spain). (E and F) Stillborn with generalized L. monocytogenes infection, a clinical condition also known as granulomatosis infantiseptica and characterized by the presence of military-disseminated pyogranulomatous lesions on the body surface (E) and internal organs (F, liver of the fetus in E) and a high mortality. (G and H) Extensive pyogranulomatous hepatitis in a lamb experimentally infected with L. ivanovii, with multiple necrotic foci in the liver surface (G) and the parenchyma (H, hematoxylin/eosin-stained cut from the liver in G, showing two subcapsular pyogranulomes [magnification, ×60]).

Listeriosis in adults. The listerial infection most frequently reported in nonpregnant adults is that affecting the CNS (55 to 70% of cases). Pure meningeal forms are observed in some cases, but infection normally develops as a meningoencephalitis accompanied by severe changes in consciousness, movement disorders, and, in some cases, paralysis of the cranial nerves (Fig. 1). The encephalitic form, in which Listeria organisms are isolated with difficulty from the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), is common in animals (Fig. 1A to D) but rare in humans (see below). Its course is usually biphasic, with an initial subfebrile phase lasting 3 to 10 days in which there may be headache, vomiting, visual disorders, and general malaise, followed in a second phase by the onset of severe signs of rhombencephalitis. The mortality rate for CNS infection is around 20% but may be as high as 40 to 60% if associated with concurrent, underlying debilitating disease. It has been estimated that L. monocytogenes accounts for 10% of community-acquired bacterial meningitis. Due to effective vaccination against Haemophilus influenzae, L. monocytogenes is now the fourth most common cause of meningeal infection in adults after Streptococcus pneumoniae, Neisseria meningitidis, and group B streptococci. However, in certain high-risk groups, such as cancer patients, L. monocytogenes is the most common cause of bacterial meningitis (391, 473, 593). Another frequent form of listeriosis (in some series of patients reported, even more frequent than CNS infection) is bacteremia or septicemia (15 to 50% of cases), with a high mortality rate (up to 70%) if it is associated with severe underlying debilitating conditions (391) (see below). There are other atypical clinical forms (5 to 10% of cases), such as endocarditis (the third most frequent form), myocarditis, arteritis, pneumonia, pleuritis, hepatitis, colecystitis, peritonitis, localized abscesses (e.g., brain abscess, which accounts for about 10% of CNS infections by Listeria spp.), arthritis, osteomyelitis, sinusitis, otitis, conjunctivitis, ophthalmitis, and, in cows, mastitis (48, 176, 199, 201, 390, 391, 395, 422-424, 550, 628).

An association between clinical episodes of invasive listeriosis and a history of gastrointestinal symptoms, including diarrhea, vomiting, and fever, was noticed some time ago (286, 542, 599). Investigations of recent food-borne outbreaks have provided compelling evidence that a febrile gastroenteritis syndrome may indeed be the main clinical manifestation of L. monocytogenes infection (19, 118, 442, 577, 628). The lesson to be learned from these epidemics is that L. monocytogenes should be sought as a possible etiologic agent in cases of diarrheagenic disease in humans. The potential enteropathogenicity of L. monocytogenes has also been recognized in animals, with outbreaks of diarrhea and gastroenteritis having been reported in sheep (52, 219, 395).

There is also a primary cutaneous form of Listeria infection characterized by a pyogranulomatous rash. This form occurs sporadically among farmers and veterinarians and is contracted by direct contact with the genital tract or placenta from cows having had a miscarriage due to Listeria infection (6, 428).

Pathogenesis

The pathophysiology of Listeria infection in humans and animals is still poorly understood. Most of the available information is derived from interpretation of epidemiological, clinical, and histopathological findings and observations made in experimental infections in animals, particularly in the murine model. As contaminated food is the major source of infection in both epidemic and sporadic cases (176, 512), the gastrointestinal tract is thought to be the primary site of entry of pathogenic Listeria organisms into the host. The clinical course of infection usually begins about 20 h after the ingestion of heavily contaminated food in cases of gastroenteritis (118), whereas the incubation period for the invasive illness is generally much longer, around 20 to 30 days (386, 542). Similar incubation periods have been reported in animals for both gastroenteric and invasive disease (138, 219, 671).

Ingestion of L. monocytogenes is likely to be a very common event, given the ubiquitous distribution of these bacteria and the high frequency of contamination of raw and industrially processed foods. However, the incidence of human listeriosis is very low, normally around 2 to 8 sporadic cases annually per million population in Europe and the United States (176, 301, 554, 649). Higher incidence rates have been reported for sporadic listeriosis (for example, 10.9 cases per million population per year in Barcelona, Spain [476], and 14.7 in France [234]), but these are exceptional. In epidemic situations, the incidence in the target population increases by a factor of 3 to 10 (46, 386, 587, 599). Thus, L. monocytogenes seems to have a lower pathogenic potential than other food-borne pathogens. This is consistent with the relatively high 50% lethal dose (LD50) values reported for mice infected experimentally by the oral (109 [18, 485]) or parenteral (105 to 106 [18, 333, 553]) routes. The minimum dose required to cause clinical infection in humans has not been determined, but the large numbers of L. monocytogenes bacteria detected in foods responsible for epidemic and sporadic cases of listeriosis (typically 106) suggest that it is high. However, these data should be interpreted with caution, given the long incubation period of invasive listeriosis and the time normally elapsed between diagnosis and analysis of the food eaten, during which Listeria organisms can have multiplied in the patient's refrigerator. It therefore cannot be excluded that low doses may be able to cause infection, at least in immunosuppressed persons, old people, and pregnant women. Indeed, levels of contamination as low as 102 to 104 L. monocytogenes cells per g of food have been associated with listeriosis in humans (176, 425). Obviously, the infectious dose may vary depending upon the pathogenicity and virulence of the L. monocytogenes strain involved and the host risk factors.

Pathogenicity of L. monocytogenes. Heterogeneity in the virulence of L. monocytogenes has been observed in several in vivo (mice) and in vitro (cell culture) studies (68, 129, 550, 663), but in most cases a clear correlation between the level of virulence and the origin or type characteristics of the strain could not be established. However, a recent study has found statistically significant differences in virulence between strains of food and clinical origin, the latter having slightly lower lethal doses (477). On the other hand, there is ample circumstantial evidence for an association between antigenic composition and pathogenicity in Listeria spp. The clearest example is provided by the L. ivanovii-specific serovar 5, which is recovered almost exclusively from ruminants, especially sheep. In these animals, serovar 5 strains cause perinatal infections but not encephalitis, the most typical clinical manifestations of ovine listeriosis (134, 397, 606, 610, 693) (Fig. 1A to D). Further evidence comes from the fact that only 3 of the 12 known serovars of L. monocytogenes, 1/2a, 1/2b, and 4b, account for more than 90% of human and animal cases of listeriosis (176, 397, 594), although other serovars, such as 1/2c, are often found as food contaminants (172, 176). Among the listeriosis-associated serovars, 4b strains cause over 50% of listeriosis cases worldwide, but strains of antigenic group 1/2 (1/2a, 1/2b, and 1/2c) predominate in food isolates (52, 172, 550, 557, 591). This suggests that serovar 4b strains are more adapted to mammalian host tissues than strains from serogroup 1/2. A phenotypically and genomically closely related group of serovar 4b isolates was found to be responsible for major outbreaks of food-borne human listeriosis in California in 1985 (386), Switzerland from 1983 to 1987 (46), Denmark from 1985 to 1987 (580), and France in 1992 (233), supporting the notion that some clones of L. monocytogenes may be particularly pathogenic (302, 510).

A number of observations suggest that there may be differences in pathogenic tropism between L. monocytogenes' strains. In humans, for example, serovar 4b strains have been found to occur more frequently in fetomaternal cases than in cases not associated with pregnancy (424). In sheep, the two major clinical forms of L. monocytogenes infection, meningoencephalitis and abortion, do not tend to occur simultaneously in the same flock (13, 397, 671). Molecular epidemiological evidence for such pathogenic tropism has been presented recently by Wiedman et al. (696). These authors found a correlation between the three serovar-related evolutionary branches into which L. monocytogenes isolates can be grouped (44, 510, 531, 678) and the pathogenic potential for humans and animals. Thus, one group of strains (serovars 1/2b and 4b) contained all isolates from human food-borne epidemics and isolates from sporadic cases in humans and animals, another (serovars 1/2a, 1/2c, and 3a) contained strains from both human and animal cases but no isolates from human food-borne epidemics, while a third group (serovar 4a) contained only animal isolates. A specific ribotype in the first group comprised all the serovar 4b strains associated with human food-borne epidemics but less than 10% of the ruminant isolates, suggesting a possible pathogenic tropism for humans (696). This possible tropism for humans of certain clones of L. monocytogenes serovar 4b may explain, for example, the observations made in Scotland, where during the same time period serovar 4b was most commonly isolated from human cases, whereas most ruminant cases were due to serovar 1/2a strains (397). There are also indications of adaptation to cause a particular clinical form in L. monocytogenes serovar 4b strains, as deduced from the analysis of two food-borne outbreaks of human listeriosis in France in 1992 and 1993, each associated with a different phage type of this serovar. In these outbreaks, the target population was similar but there was a significant difference in the percentage of fetomaternal cases (33 versus 80%) (557, 558).

Host risk factors. Host susceptibility plays a major role in the presentation of clinical disease upon exposure to L. monocytogenes. Thus, most listeriosis patients have a physiological or pathological defect that affects T-cell-mediated immunity. This justifies the classification of L. monocytogenes as an opportunisitic pathogen. The groups at risk for listeriosis are pregnant women and neonates, the elderly (55 to 60 years and older), and immunocompromised or debilitated adults with underlying diseases. Listeriosis in nonpregnant adults is associated in most cases (>75%) with at least one of the following conditions: malignancies (leukemia, lymphoma, or sarcoma) and antineoplastic chemotherapy, immunosuppresant therapy (organ transplantation or corticosteroid use), chronic liver disease (cirrhosis or alcoholism), kidney disease, diabetes, and collagen disease (lupus) (176, 423, 551, 554, 594).

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is also a significant risk factor for listeriosis. AIDS is the underlying predisposing condition in 5 to 20% of listeriosis cases in nonpregnant adults. It has been estimated that the risk of contracting listeriosis is 300 to 1,000 times higher for AIDS patients than for the general population. Nevertheless, listeriosis remains a relatively rare AIDS-associated infection, probably due to the preventive dietary measures taken by HIV-infected patients (avoidance of high-risk foods), the antimicrobial treatments that they receive regularly to treat or prevent opportunistic infections, and the fact that HIV infection does not significantly reduce the activity of the major effectors of immunity of Listeria spp. (innate immune mechanisms and the CD8+ T-cell subset [266]) (35, 306, 316, 592).

The health status of the patient greatly influences the outcome of listeriosis. Immunocompetent patients usually survive listeriosis, whereas those with underlying debilitating diseases often succumb to the infection (mean mortality rate for this group, >30 to 40%) (235, 627). Although most listeriosis cases are associated with underlying risk factors, there are also a few adult patients for whom no obvious predisposing condition can be identified (177, 233, 235). This shows that L. monocytogenes has the potential to infect immunocompetent individuals. In some epidemics, all the nonpregnant adult patients had preexisting illnesses or immunosuppresive conditions (180, 386), whereas in others no such predisposing factors were found in any of the nonperinatal cases (587). This may be due to differences in the bacterial load present in the contaminated food involved or to the degree of virulence of the corresponding strains of L. monocytogenes.

Entry and colonization of host tissues.

(i) Crossing the intestinal barrier. Before reaching the intestine, the ingested Listeria organisms must withstand the adverse environment of the stomach (Fig. 2). Oral infective doses are lower for cimetidine-treated experimental animals than for untreated animals (586a), and the use of antacids and H2-blocking agents has been reported to be a risk factor for listeriosis (286, 592). This indicates that gastric acidity may destroy a significant number of the Listeria organisms ingested with contaminated food.


View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIG. 2.   Schematic representation of the pathophysiology of Listeria infection. See text for details.

There is controversy concerning the point of entry and the mechanism of intestinal translocation used by L. monocytogenes. In an early study by Racz et al. with guinea pigs infected intragastrically with 1010 L. monocytogenes, detailed histological analyses revealed that all the animals developed enteritis (526). In the initial stages, bacteria were detected mostly in the absorptive epithelial cells of the apical area of the villi, whereas in later phases most were inside macrophages of the stroma of the villi, suggesting that L. monocytogenes penetrates the host by invading the intestinal epithelium (526). This is consistent with the observation that L. monocytogenes is able to penetrate the apical surface of polarized, differentiated human enterocyte-like Caco-2 cells with a brush border (322) (see Fig. 3B and C). In other studies using mice inoculated per os with 108 to 109 bacteria, no invasion of the intestinal villous epithelium was observed; instead, there was colonization of the Peyer's patches (400, 410, 411), suggesting that L. monocytogenes uses the M-cell epithelium as an entry portal, as reported for other bacterial pathogens (623). Direct evidence that L. monocytogenes may indeed penetrate the host via the M cells overlying the Peyer's patches has been provided by a recent study using a murine ligated-loop model and scanning electron microscopy (308). However, listerial penetration at this level appears not to be very efficient, because only small numbers of bacteria are observed in association with the follicle-associated epithelium overlying Peyer's patches (411).

Intestinal translocation of pathogenic listeriae occurs without the formation of gross macroscopic or histological lesions in the gut of mice (411). This suggests that an epithelial phase involving bacterial multiplication in the intestinal mucosa is not required by L. monocytogenes for systemic infection. Indeed, a recent study using a rat ileal loop model of intestinal infection (523) has shown that Listeria organisms are translocated to deep organs very rapidly (within a few minutes), demonstrating that crossing of the intestinal barrier occurs in the absence of prior intraepithelial replication. This study also showed that defined mutants defective in virulence factors known to be involved in epithelial cell invasion (InlA and InlB), intracellular survival (Hly), and cell-to-cell spread (ActA) (see below), and even the nonpathogenic species L. innocua, translocated at the same rate as wild-type L. monocytogenes. Translocation was dose dependent, and the presence of Peyer's patches in ligated loops did not affect the rate of translocation, levels of uptake being similarly low for Peyer's patches and villous intestine (50 to 250 bacteria per cm2 of tissue after inoculation of the loop with 109 bacteria) (523). These findings favor the view that listerial translocation is a passive, nonspecific process similar to that observed for other bacteria (36), at least in mice and rats. However, L. monocytogenes proliferated in the intestinal wall, whereas L. innocua did not. The preferential site for bacterial replication was the Peyer's patches, and the essential listerial virulence factor Hly (hemolysin) was indispensable for this process, showing that L. monocytogenes establishes an active local infection in these lymphoid structures of the intestine. The foci of infection consisted of pyogranulomatous reactions in the subepithelial follicular tissue, with bacteria visible inside permissive mononuclear cells, presumably nonactivated resident macrophages and dendritic cells (522a, 523). Thus, antigen presentation events probably already take place in the intestine during the early phases of host colonization, and this may play an important role in the acquired resistance to subsequent reinfection that develops after primary oral exposure to L. monocytogenes (394, 400). A recent study has shown that invasion of intestinal epithelial cells by L. monocytogenes induces the activation of NF-kappa B and the subsequent upregulation of interleukin-15 (IL-15), and that at early stages of an oral infection with L. monocytogenes in mice and rats, intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes become activated and produce Th1-type cytokines. This suggests that the interaction between intestinal epithelial and lymphoid cells may be relevant in the local host defence against listerial infection in the gut (706).

Experimental observations made with the mouse and rat models of intestinal translocation do not, however, explain how L. monocytogenes causes enteritis. The association of gastroenteric symptoms with fever is consistent with invasive intestinal disease, as observed by Racz in the guinea pig model (526). Pathogenic Listeria organisms pass directly from cell to cell by a mechanism involving host cell actin polymerization (see below). Therefore, regardless of the mechanism of entry used, the bacteria that penetrate the intestinal wall might then invade neighboring enterocytes by basolateral spread, leading to enteritis. This is consistent with in vitro experimental data showing that L. monocytogenes enters polarized Caco-2 cells predominantly via the basolateral surface (196). Gross intestinal lesions develop in experimental animals only if large oral doses of L. monocytogenes are given (400, 523). Similarly, episodes of listerial gastroenteritis in humans occur in the form of outbreaks with very short incubation periods and high attack rates among immunocompetent adults (118, 577), consistent with the ingestion of a very high dose of bacteria (as high as 2.9 × 1011, as estimated for one of these oubreaks, caused by the consumption of heavily contaminated chocolate milk [118]). Thus, intestinal invasion and the ensuing febrile gastroenteritis syndrome probably result from extensive exposure of the intestine to pathogenic Listeria organisms. However, the possibility that some L. monocytogenes strains have a greater enteropathogenic potential and cause intestinal damage at a lower dose cannot be ruled out.

(ii) Multiplication in the liver. The Listeria organisms that cross the intestinal barrier are carried by the lymph or blood to the mesenteric lymph nodes, the spleen, and the liver (411, 523) (Fig. 2). As stated above, this initial step of host tissue colonization by L. monocytogenes is rapid. The unusually long incubation period required by L. monocytogenes for the development of symptomatic systemic infection after oral exposure in relation to that for other food-borne pathogens is therefore puzzling and indicates that listerial colonization of host tissues involves a silent, subclinical phase, many of the events and underlying mechanisms of which are unknown.

Experimental infections of mice via the intravenous route have shown that L. monocytogenes bacteria are rapidly cleared from the bloodstream by resident macrophages in the spleen and liver (99, 112a, 405). Most (90%) of the bacterial load accumulates in the liver, presumably captured by the Kupffer cells that line the sinusoids. These resident macrophages kill most of the ingested bacteria, as shown by in vivo depletion experiments (161), resulting in a decrease in the size of the viable bacterial population in the liver during the first 6 h after infection. Kupffer cells are believed to initiate the development of antilisterial immunity by inducing the antigen-dependent proliferation of T lymphocytes and the secretion of cytokines (243). Not all Listeria cells are destroyed by tissue macrophages, and the surviving bacteria start to grow, increasing in numbers for 2 to 5 days in mouse organs (93, 99, 128, 181, 381, 408, 448).

The principal site of bacterial multiplication in the liver is the hepatocyte (100, 112a, 197, 241, 241a, 563). This finding has led to the dismissal of the long-held idea that the major host niche for the parasitic life of L. monocytogenes is the macrophage population. There are two possible ways for L. monocytogenes to gain access to the liver parenchyma after its intestinal translocation and carriage by the portal or arterial bloodstream: via Kupffer cells, by cell to cell spread, or by the direct invasion of hepatocytes from the Disse space after crossing the fenestrated endothelial barrier lining the sinusoids. L. monocytogenes has been shown to efficiently invade hepatocytes in vitro (149, 701).

Electron microscopy of hepatic tissue from infected mice suggests that L. monocytogenes goes through the complete intracellular infectious cycle in hepatocytes (197, 621), including actin-based intercellular spread (see below). Direct passage from hepatocyte to hepatocyte would lead to the formation of infectious foci in which L. monocytogenes disseminates through the liver parenchyma without coming into contact with the humoral effectors of the immune system. This may explain why antibodies play no major role in anti-Listeria immunity (516).

During the early steps of liver colonization, polymorphonuclear neutrophils are recruited at the sites of infection, forming discrete microabscesses. Neutrophils have been shown to play an important role in controlling the acute phase of Listeria infection (561) and in mediating the destruction of Listeria-infected hepatocytes in vivo (99). Hepatocytes respond to Listeria infection by releasing neutrophil chemoattractants and exhibiting an increase in adhesion to neutrophils, resulting in microabscess formation (560). They also respond by initiating an apoptosis program that may be critical for removing Listeria-infected cells from the liver tissue at early stages of infection (448a, 560). Using transgenic mice expressing a degradation-resistant Ikappa B transgene, it has been shown recently that NF-kappa B activation in mouse hepatocytes is essential to clear L. monocytogenes from the liver, possibly by coordinating local innate immune response (368). Two to four days after infection, neutrophils are gradually replaced by blood-derived mononuclear cells together with lymphocytes to form the characteristic granulomas (283, 408) (Fig. 1G and H). These granulomas are the histomorphological correlate of cell-mediated immunity and presumably act as true physical barriers that confine the infectious foci, impeding further bacterial dissemination by direct cell-to-cell passage (516).

Between days 5 and 7 postinfection, L. monocytogenes bacteria start to disappear from mouse organs until their complete clearance as a result of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma )-mediated macrophage activation and the induction of an acquired immune response primarily mediated by CD8+ lymphocytes, which together destroy Listeria-infected cells (241a, 268, 328, 441). These cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are directed against listerial epitopes present in secreted virulence-associated proteins, such as Hly (59, 71, 266, 281, 625, 677), the metalloprotease Mpl (79), and the surface protein p60 (203, 204, 267, 624), and possibly also in somatic housekeeping proteins such as superoxide dismutase (280). Protection against L. monocytogenes also involves a vigorous Th1-biased CD4+ T-cell response (125, 203) and innate mechanisms such as the activation of IFN-gamma -producing natural killer (NK) cells in response to IL-12 and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha ) secretion by infected macrophages (125, 166, 268, 290). Hepatocytes may contribute to protection by becoming less permissive to intracellular proliferation of Listeria organisms upon exposure to IFN-gamma (244), especially if costimulated with other cytokines (646).

The above course of events is accelerated in immune animals, resulting in rapid elimination of L. monocytogenes from the liver (Fig. 2). This is probably the most common outcome of L. monocytogenes infection in humans and animals in normal conditions, given the potentially high frequency of exposure to the pathogen via contaminated food and the relatively rare occurrence of clinical disease. Indeed, T lymphocytes directed against Listeria antigens are commonly found in healthy individuals (457), probably due to chronic stimulation of the immune system by L. monocytogenes antigens that are presumably continuously delivered to the immune system via food. A recent study has shown that the nonpathogenic species L. innocua can enhance a previously established L. monocytogenes-specific T-cell memory via recognition of cross-reactive p60 epitopes shared by the two species (204). L. innocua is commonly found in food (573), and as stated above, it is translocated to the deep organs of mice as efficiently as L. monocytogenes. Therefore, repeated contact with L. innocua may boost protective immunity against pathogenic Listeria spp., possibly explaining in part the rare occurrence of listeriosis in the general population.

If the infection is not controlled by an adequate immune response in the liver, as may occur in immunocompromised individuals, unlimited proliferation of L. monocytogenes in the liver parenchyma may result in the release of bacteria into the circulation (Fig. 2). L. monocytogenes is a multisystemic pathogen that can infect a wide range of host tissues, as indicated by its capacity to cause septicemia involving multiple organs and by the variety of potential sites of localized Listeria infection (see above). However, the principal clinical forms of listeriosis clearly show that L. monocytogenes has a pathogenic tropism towards the gravid uterus and the CNS (Fig. 2).

(iii) Colonization of gravid uterus and fetus. Abortion and stillbirth due to Listeria spp. have been reproduced experimentally by intravenous, oral, and respiratory inoculation in naturally susceptible gestating animal hosts, such as sheep, cattle, rabbits, and guinea pigs, as well in pregnant mice and rats (1, 238, 239, 329, 450, 487, 488, 586). This shows that L. monocytogenes gains access to the fetus by hematogenous penetration of the placental barrier (Fig. 2). In pregnant mice, the blood-borne bacteria first invade the decidua basalis and then progress to the placental villi, where they cause diffuse inflammatory infiltration and necrosis (1, 535, 536). Macrophages appear to be excluded from the murine placenta, neutrophils acting as the main antilisterial effector cell population (251a). Using homozygous mutant mice, it has been shown recently that colony-stimulating factor-1 is required for the recruitment of neutrophils to the infectious foci in the decidua basalis. This occurs via induction of neutrophil chemoattractant synthesis by the trophoblast (251a). In humans, placental infection is characterized by numerous microabscesses and focal necrotizing villitis (502, 582). Colonization of the trophoblast layer followed by translocation across the endothelial barrier would enable the bacteria to reach the fetal bloodstream, leading to generalized infection and subsequent death of the fetus in utero or to premature birth of a severely infected neonate with miliary pyogranulomatous lesions (the above-mentioned granulomatosis infantiseptica) (Fig. 1E and F).

The depression of cell-mediated immunity during pregnancy (686) presumably plays an important role in the development of listeriosis. In laboratory rodents, pregnancy reduces resistance to L. monocytogenes (58, 399) and significantly prolongs the course of primary infection in the liver (1). The T-cell-dependent elimination of L. monocytogenes from the organs of pregnant mice is delayed in late pregnancy. This correlates with a failure in the production of IFN-gamma and results in listerial invasion of placental and fetal tissues (463). Abnormally high physiological levels of estrogenic hormones, such as those that occur during late pregnancy, may account for the disruption of T-cell-mediated resistance to infection, as treatment of mice with steroids inhibits the proliferative response to L. monocytogenes of splenic T cells and increases susceptibility to Listeria infection (524). This correlates with a decrease in the production of IL-2 (524), a cytokine that stimulates resistance to Listeria spp. in mice (255). The intracellular killing function of macrophages has also been shown to be decreased by beta -estradiol, which is associated with inhibition of both IL-12 and TNF-alpha secretion in vivo (578). Local depression in the cellular immune response in the placenta, which physiologically is important for preventing rejection of the fetus, may also contribute to the higher susceptibility to uterine infection by L. monocytogenes (398, 535, 536). It is not known why mothers suffering Listeria-induced miscarriage never develop CNS infection or overt septicemic disease.

(iv) Invasion of the brain. In humans, CNS infection by Listeria spp. presents primarily in the form of meningitis. This meningitis, however, is often associated with the presence of infectious foci in the brain parenchyma, especially in the brain stem (391, 473), suggesting L. monocytogenes has a tropism for nerve tissue. The neurotropism and special predilection of L. monocytogenes for the rhombencephalon are shown most clearly in ruminants, in which listerial CNS infection, in contrast to the situation in humans, develops mainly as primary encephalitis. In these animals, infectious foci are restricted to the pons, medulla oblongata, and spinal cord (Fig. 1C). Although there is inflammatory lymphocyte or mononuclear cell infiltration of the meninges, this condition occurs as an extension of the brain process, and macroscopic lesions may not even be evident or may be restricted to basal areas, midbrain, and cerebellum. Unilateral cranial nerve paralysis is a characteristic of listerial rhombencephalitis in ruminants, leading to the well-known circling disease syndrome (92, 103, 215, 216, 312, 534, 666, 693) (Fig. 1A and B). In humans, primary nonmeningeal brain infection is seldom observed. However, as in ruminants, it develops as cerebritis involving the rhombencephalon (15, 20, 69, 390, 391, 473).

Brain lesions in listerial meningoencephalitis are typical and very similar in humans and animals. They consist of perivascular cuffs of inflammatory infiltrates composed of mononuclear cells and scattered neutrophils and lymphocytes (Fig. 1D). Bacteria are generally absent from these perivascular areas of inflammation. Parenchymal microabscesses and foci of necrosis and malacia are also typically present (Fig. 1D). Bacteria are relatively abundant in these lesions, within phagocytes or free in the brain parenchyma around the necrotic areas (92, 103, 312, 315, 412, 489). Depletion experiments in mice using a neutrophil-specific monoclonal antibody have shown that neutrophils play a critical role in eliminating L. monocytogenes from infectious foci in the brain (389a). Less commonly, bacteria are observed within neurons in both natural (412, 489) and experimentally induced (588) infections. This is consistent with in vitro data showing that the invasion of cultured neurons is a relatively rare event (151, 505). However, neurons are efficiently invaded in vitro by direct cell-to-cell spread from infected macrophages or microgial cells (151). A recent study (146) has shown that L. monocytogenes can efficiently invade sensory neurons of rat dorsal root ganglia but not hippocampal neurons, suggesting that there may be differences in the susceptibility to infection among different types of neurons. The relevance of neuronal invasion to the pathogenesis of Listeria encephalitis is subject to speculation, as discussed below.

The mechanisms by which L. monocytogenes infects the CNS are still largely unknown. Numerous attempts have been made to reproduce listerial meningoencephalitis in susceptible animal hosts and laboratory rodents using various routes of inoculation, with variable success. Intravenous delivery of the inoculum does not usually result in CNS infection in sheep (103). This, and the usual absence of visceral involvement in natural cases of ovine listerial encephalitis, seems to argue against a hematogenous route of infection. The topographic distribution of the lesions in sheep, strictly confined to the brainstem, and the frequent unilateral involvement of the trigeminal nerve, with neuritis affecting distal portions of a single or a few fasciculi in only one of the nerve branches, led to the hypothesis that L. monocytogenes invades the brain by centripetal migration along cranial nerves (17, 92, 661). To test this hypothesis, Asahi and coworkers (17) scarified oral, nasal, and labial mucosae of mice with L. monocytogenes. Most mice developed neurological signs, such as torticollis, rolling movements, and paralysis of the hindlegs, 5 days after infection. These signs correlated with the presence of mononuclear and round cell infiltrations along the trigeminal nerve, in the corresponding nerve ganglion, and in the medulla oblongata, suggesting retrograde bacterial ascension along the cranial nerve to the brainstem. In another experiment, 4 of 11 goats inoculated in the lip developed listerial encephalitis 17 to 28 days after inoculation, with microscopic lesions identical to those found in natural cases of listeriosis, with ganglioneuritis of the trigeminal nerve (17). In spontaneous cases of ovine listerial encephalits, bacteria have been observed in linear arrays in individual nerve fibers, inside axons, and with actin tails (91, 92, 489), suggesting active intra-axonal movement. Experiments using a double-chamber cell culture system and dorsal root ganglia neurons provided evidence that L. monocytogenes can infect axons and spread along them towards the nerve cell body (146).

Experimental evidence has been obtained that intra-axonal bacterial transport may indeed occur in vivo. Otter and Blakemore (489) developed a mouse model in which L. monocytogenes was injected distally into the sciatic nerve. Paralysis of the leg into which the bacteria were injected occurred 7 to 12 days later, and examination of the spinal cord revealed lesions very similar to those found in the brains of naturally affected sheep. Bacteria were seen in these lesions in neutrophils and, in some cases, in axons (489). The feasibility of ascending intra-axonal transport via the termini of the trigeminal nerve was tested by experimentally injecting L. monocytogenes directly into the dental pulp of sheep through a hole drilled in the tooth crown (22). Six of 21 sheep developed neurological signs 20 to 40 days after challenge, and most animals showed histological encephalitis and trigeminal ganglioneuritis on the side of inoculation. These observations favor the view that L. monocytogenes may directly invade exposed sensory terminal ramifications of the cranial nerve in the mouth and reach the brain by centripetal spread. They also demonstrate that cases of mild CNS invasion by Listeria organisms may occur without overt clinical signs. This is important because it provides one possible explanation for the relatively small number of cases with neurological manifestations that are observed among animals exposed to contaminated silage in a herd affected by listerial encephalitis (and, by extension, to humans exposed to Listeria-contaminated food). However, in another study in which brains from natural cases of sheep with meningoencephalitis were analyzed, inflammatory infiltration was observed only in the intracranial portion of the trigeminal tract, always associated with meningitis adjacent to proximal parts of cranial nerves. The authors were of the opinion that cranial nerve invasion was only secondary to a hematogenous brain infection and occurred by centrifugal spread from the brainstem (103). The above-mentioned experiments with the two-chamber model (146) suggested that both retrograde and anterograde transport of L. monocytogenes may occur inside infected neurons.

Although intravenous inoculation only occasionally gives positive results, intracarotid inoculation consistently results in encephalitis in sheep (103, 314, 486). This supports the notion that L. monocytogtenes may indeed reach the brain via the blood. Strong evidence that meningoencephalitis in ruminants has a vascular basis is provided by the nature of the brain lesions themselves, with extensive perivascular infiltrates and mononuclear microabscesses and necrotic foci developing in close proximity to brain capillaries (103) (Fig. 1D). In contrast to intravenous inoculation, intracarotid delivery provides the inoculum direct access to the vascular system of the brain, enabling bacteria to bypass the clearance mechanisms of organs such as the spleen and liver. In an immunocompetent host, these clearance mechanisms should be sufficient to eliminate rapidly a single-dose intravenous inoculum, preventing the bacteria from invading the brain. Intracarotid inoculation in sheep causes CNS lesions involving the choroid plexus and the ependyma of the cerebral ventricles and aqueduct, resulting in primary meningitis and secondary lesions in the adjoining cerebral tissues (17). These brain structures are only rarely affected in natural cases of listerial meningoencephalitis in ruminants (103). The reason for these differences between natural and experimental lesion patterns probably resides in the concentration of bacteria in the blood, as this is an important factor affecting the mode by which bacterial pathogens gain access to the CNS (659, 660). This concentration would reach an extraordinarily high peak in the brain after intracarotid delivery, and high-grade bacteremia is more likely to cause meningitis due to massive bacterial penetration across the epithelium lining the choroid plexus, which has an exceptionally high rate of blood flow. In contrast, low-grade bacteremia, such as that resulting from the release of bacteria into the blood from infectious foci located in distant organs (e.g., the liver), tends to be associated with multiple foci in the brain parenchyma due to individual penetrations along the extensive microvascular endothelial bed (660).

Experimental infections in small laboratory animals also provide evidence for a hematogenous route of CNS invasion for L. monocytogenes. Intravenous inoculation in mice results in meningoencephalitis in a significant proportion of animals that survive the initial systemic phase of infection. Lesions include choroiditis, meningitis, and the characteristic perivascular cuffing and parenchymal pyogranulomatous foci in the brainstem (31, 103). No brain invasion is detected in mice challenged with low infective doses that induce only transient bacteremia, even if there is significant bacterial multiplication in the spleen and liver. However, brain invasion is achieved with high infective doses causing severe systemic disease and prolonged bacteremia (31). This suggests that the persistence of large numbers of bacteria in the blood is essential for the induction of meningoencephalitis by L. monocytogenes. This conclusion is consistent with a recent study by Blanot and coworkers (47), who adapted a model of otitis media in gerbils to study listerial CNS invasion. With a low infective dose of L. monocytogenes (103/ear), these authors induced persistent low-level bacteremia (102 bacteria/ml) which was associated with the development of rhombencephalitis in gerbils mimicking that observed during human listerial meningoencephalitis, with leptomeningitis, parenchymal foci, and perivascular sheaths. The number of bacteria in the liver and spleen of gerbils decreased by day 5 postinoculation, but growth in brain tissue was unrestricted (47), suggesting that nerve tissue is a privileged niche for the multiplication of L. monocytogenes. CNS invasion was also regularly observed in mice after oral or subcutaneous inoculation (9, 17, 522). These infection routes imply systemic involvement and, clearly, also lymphohematogenous dissemination of bacteria to the brain.

In experiments with orally or subcutaneously infected mice, parenchymal brain lesions are irregularly observed, but marked inflammatory lesions in the meninges and ventricular system (choroid plexus, lateral, third and fourth ventricles, and aqueduct) are consistently recorded (9, 522). This striking affinity of L. monocytogenes for mouse ventricular structures was also noted after direct intracerebral inoculation (588), which prevents primary blood-borne exposure of the ependyma via the choroid plexus. In contrast, no involvement of the ventricular system was noticed in the gerbil model (47). These observations suggest that there may be anatomical and physiological differences in the brains of the various animal species that affect L. monocytogenes neuropathogenesis. Indeed, this may account for the differential characteristics of listerial CNS infection in humans and ruminants. However, it cannot be excluded that the peculiar characteristics of listerial meningoencephalitis in ruminants result from the fact that an alternative primary nonvascular mechanism of CNS invasion, which may perfectly coexist with hematogenous dissemination, has specifically evolved in these animals. Ruminants eat plant material, the physical characteristics of which may lead to small breaches of the oral mucosa. If animals are fed contaminated silage, these small wounds are repeatedly exposed to L. monocytogenes during rumination, favoring invasion of the trigeminal nerve terminals and subsequent intraneural, direct spread to the brain stem.

Bacterial pathogens such as H. influenzae, N. meningitidis, S. pneumoniae, and Streptococcus suis cross the blood-brain barrier (BBB) primarily via the choroid plexus. This enables them to reach the CSF and create purulent meningitis by spreading through the subarachnoid space (525, 659, 660, 697). Although in human listerial infections of the CNS, purulent meningitis also occurs and bacteria may also be detected in the CSF, it is clear that L. monocytogenes, unlike other meningitis-causing bacterial pathogens, tends to affect brain parenchymal tissue. This may reflect a tropism for the microvascular endothelium, in particular that lining the capillary bed of the rhombencephalon, resulting in significant or preferential (in ruminants) crossing of the BBB at this point. Direct uptake by endothelial cells of bacteria circulating free in the blood is one possible mechanism by which L. monocytogenes may cross the microvascular BBB. Evidence for this mechanism is provided by an electron microscopic study of human brainstem tissue, in which bacteria have been observed within endothelial cells or adhering to the luminal face of the microvascular endothelium (335). This mechanism is also consistent with in vitro data showing that L. monocytogenes is able to invade cultured human brain microvascular endothelial cells (BMEC) (245, 246). The listerial surface protein InlB, of the internalin family (see below), has been shown to be required for invasion of endothelial cells in vitro (246, 498), indicating that specific bacterial molecules are actively involved in the interaction with the BBB. L. monocytogenes efficiently replicates for long periods of time within brain microvascular cells without causing any evident damage, creating heavily infected foci from which bacteria spread to neighboring cells by actin-based motility (246). In this way, L. monocytogenes may reach and disseminate easily into the protected spaces of the CNS.

L. monocytogenes infection induces a potent response in cultured endothelial cells which is accompanied by the upregulation of endothelial adhesion molecules (P- and E-selectin, ICAM-1, and VCAM-1) (see below), leading to an increase in the binding of polymorphonuclear leukocytes to infected endothelial cells (152, 247, 330, 600, 618). Heterologous plaque assays using infected macrophages as vectors have demonstrated that L. monocytogenes can spread efficiently from macrophages into endothelial cells (157, 246). Therefore, the recruitment of phagocytes to the infected endothelium, primarily a host defense response, may also be used by L. monocytogenes, in addition to direct invasion, to cross the BBB. Evidence for a significant role in vivo for such a Trojan horse mechanism of CNS invasion, presumably involving direct bacterial cell-to-cell spread from infected phagocytes carried by the blood after adhesion to endothelial cells, has been provided recently by Drevets (154). This author showed that phagocyte-associated L. monocytogenes accounted for 30% of the total bacterial population circulating in the bloodstream after intravenous inoculation. These entrapped bacteria spread to endothelial cells in vitro, and Listeria-infected peripheral blood leukocytes successfully established brain colonization in vivo (154). It is unknown whether trafficking of infected phagocytes across the BBB, as part of the inflammatory influx induced by endothelial and underlying brain tissue infection, occurs in vivo during CNS invasion by L. monocytogenes.

Hypothetical scenario. From the information presented above, the following hypothetical scenario for the pathogenesis of listeriosis can be proposed. Clinical outcome of Listeria infection depends on three major variables: (i) the number of bacteria ingested with food, (ii) the pathogenic properties of the strain, and (iii) the immunological status of the host. In immunocompetent individuals with no predisposing conditions, ingestion of low doses of L. monocytogenes will probably have no effect other than the development or boosting of antilisterial protective immunity. In contrast, oral exposure to large doses is likely to result in an episode of gastroenteritis and fever and, depending on the virulence of the strain, possible invasive disease. Immunocompromised and debilitated individuals, however, cannot mount an immune response strong enough to control bacterial proliferation in the liver, the primary target organ of L. monocytogenes, and are therefore susceptible to invasive disease following the ingestion of a lower inoculum. Inefficiently restricted growth of L. monocytogenes in the hepatocytes in these individuals is likely to result in an increase in the critical mass of bacteria and their release into the bloodstream. The ensuing prolonged bacteremia will result in local infections in secondary target organs (particularly the brain and placenta) or in septicemic disease in severely immunocompromised hosts. Figure 2 summarizes the key steps of the pathophysiology of Listeria infection.


INTRACELLULAR INFECTIOUS CYCLE
Top
Previous
Next
References

In addition to multiplying within macrophages, Listeria organisms are invasive pathogens that can induce their own internalization in various types of cell that are not normally phagocytic. These include epithelial cells (194, 435, 518), fibroblasts (359, 641), hepatocytes (149, 242, 701), endothelial cells (157, 245, 498), and various types of nerve cell, including neurons (151). Listeria organisms have been also shown to be taken up by and survive within dentritic cells (253, 345). In the interior of all cells that L. monocytogenes is able to penetrate, whether macrophages or nonprofessional phagocytes, it develops an intracellular life cycle with common characteristics (Fig. 3).


View larger version (126K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
FIG. 3.   Stages of listerial intracellular parasitism. (A) Scheme of the intracellular life cycle of pathogenic Listeria spp. (reproduced from reference 655 with permission of the Rockefeller University Press). In anticlockwise order: entry into the host cell by induced phagocytosis, transient residence within a phagocytic vacuole, escape from the phagosome into the cytoplasm, cytosolic replication and recruitment of host cell actin onto the bacterial surface, actin-based motility, formation of pseudopods, phagocytosis of the pseudopods by neighboring cells, formation of a double-membrane phagosome, escape from this secondary phagosome, and reinitiation of the cycle. (B to H) Scanning and transmission electron micrographs of cell monolayers infected with L. monocytogenes (B) Numerous bacteria adhering to the microvilli of a Caco-2 cell (30 min after infection). (C) Two bacteria in the process of invasion (Caco-2 cell, 30 min postinfection). (D) Two intracellular bacteria soon after phagocytosis, still surrounded by the membranes of the phagocytic vacuole (Caco-2 cell, 1 h postinfection). (E) Intracellular Listeria cells free in the host cell cytoplasm after escape from the phagosome (Caco-2 cell, 2 h postinfection). (F) Pseudopod-like membrane protrusion induced by moving Listeria cells, with the bacterium being evident at the tip (brain microvascular endothelial cell, 4 h postinfection; taken from reference 245 with permission). (G) Section of a pseudopod-like structure in which a thin cytoplasmic extension of an infected cell is protruding into a neighboring noninfected cell (notice that the protrusion is covered by two membranes) (Caco-2 cell, 4 h postinfection). (H) Bacteria in a double-membrane vacuole formed during cell-to-cell spread (Caco-2 cell, 4 h postinfection).

Internalization

The cycle begins with adhesion to the surface of the eukaryote cell and subsequent penetration of the bacterium into the host cell. The invasion of nonphagocytic cells involves a zipper-type mechanism, in that the bacterium gradually sinks into diplike structures of the host cell surface until it is finally engulfed. During this process, the target cell membrane closely surrounds the bacterial cell and does not form the spectacular local processes or membrane ruffles characteristic of invasion by Salmonella and Shigella spp. (147, 322, 358, 435, 642) (Fig. 3B and C). The structures, mechanisms, and signal transduction cascades involved in the interaction between the bacterium and the cell during phagocytosis are only beginning to be elucidated.

The multisystemic nature of listerial infection indicates that L. monocytogenes probably recognizes a number of different eukaryotic receptors. The C3bi and C1q complement receptors have been reported to be involved in L. monocytogenes uptake by phagocytic cells (10, 115, 155, 156). L. monocytogenes is also efficiently internalized in the absence of serum, indicating that nonopsonic receptor-ligand interactions are also involved in host cell recognition by Listeria spp. (509). The eukaryote cell receptors used by Listeria spp. include the transmembrane glycoprotein E-cadherin (435), the C1q complement fraction receptor (61), the Met receptor for hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) (615a), and components of the extracellular matrix (ECM) such as heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG) (12) and fibronectin (217). The macrophage scavenger receptor was shown to bind L. monocytogenes lipoteichoic acids and hence may also be involved in Listeria-macrophage interactions (160, 240). The bacterial ligands identified to date are all surface proteins, such as the internalins InlA and InlB, the actin-polymerizing protein ActA, and p60 (see below). Recently, several putative adhesion factors of L. monocytogenes have been identified by screening transposon mutants for defective attachment to eukaryotic cells. Among these putative adhesins are the surface protein Ami, an autolysin with a C-terminal cell wall-anchoring domain similar to InlB (60, 429, 445) (see below), and Lap, a 104-kDa surface protein involved in attachment to Caco-2 cells (581a). Also recently, a 24.6-kDa fibronectin-binding protein has been identified in L. monocytogenes by screening a genomic library in Escherichia coli for fibronectin binding (215). Bacterium-host cell interactions involving lectins (482) may also be involved in L. monocytogenes adhesion to eukaryotic cells (174). Indirect evidence has been obtained for an L. monocytogenes adhesin containing alpha -D-galactose, involved in uptake by mouse CB1 dendritic cells (253) and human HepG22 hepatocarcinoma cells (114) upon recognition of a carbohydrate receptor at the eukaryotic cell surface. The presence in L. monocytogenes of lectin-like ligands mediating binding to D-glucosamine, L-fucosylamine, and p-aminophenyl-alpha -D-mannopyranoside moieties has also been indirectly demonstrated (110).

Intracellular Proliferation and Intercellular Spread

During invasion, Listeria bacteria become engulfed within a phagocytic vacuole (194) (Fig. 3D). Little is known about the characteristics of the Listeria-containing vacuolar compartment, but the vacuoles become acidified soon after uptake (25). There is evidence that L. monocytogenes ensures its intravacuolar viability by preventing phagosome maturation to the phagolysosomal stage (11). Thirty minutes after entry, the bacteria begin to disrupt the phagosome membrane (194), and within 2 h, about 50% of the intracellular bacterial population is free in the cytoplasm (655) (Fig. 3E). This membrane disruption step is essential for listerial intracellular survival and proliferation (220) and is mediated by the hemolysin in combination with phospholipases (see below).

Once in the cytosol, bacteria multiply (Fig. 3E), with a doubling time of approximately 1 h (194, 518), i.e., approximately three times slower than in rich medium. In L. monocytogenes, intracellular growth does not involve the upregulation of known stress proteins (261) (see below), and auxotrophic mutants requiring aromatic amino acids or purines for growth in minimal medium grow inside cells at rates similar to those of the wild-type parent strain (413). This indicates that the cytoplasmic compartment is permissive for Listeria proliferation. However, three metabolic genes (purH, purD, and pyrE, involved in purine and pyrimidine biosynthesis) and an arginine ABC transporter (arpJ) have been shown to be induced within cells (336). Mutation of these genes had no major effect on intracellular proliferation and virulence (336), which can mean that certain nutrients are present in the host cell cytoplasm at concentrations that, although not limiting, are sufficiently low that L. monocytogenes has to upregulate certain metabolic genes to grow efficiently within cells. Recent experimental evidence indicates that pathogenic Listeria spp. may exploit hexose phosphates from the host cell cytoplasm for efficient intracellular growth (543) (see below). Evidence has also been recently presented that antimicrobial peptides from the host cell cytosol, such as ubiquicidin found in macrophages (283a), may play a role in restraining intracellular proliferation of L. monocytogenes. Nothing is known about the listerial mechanisms counteracting these inhibitory peptides.

Intracytoplasmic bacteria are immediately surrounded by a cloud of a fine, fuzzy, fibrillar material composed of actin filaments, which later (around 2 h postinfection) rearranges to form an actin tail of up to 40 µm at one of the poles of the bacterium (see Fig. 6B). This actin tail consists of two populations of cross-linked actin filaments, one formed by relatively long, axially arranged actin bundles and the other by shorter, randomly arranged filaments. The polar assembly of actin filaments propels the bacterial cell in the cytoplasm with a mean speed of 0.3 µm/s, in a fashion reminiscent of the "action-reaction" principle that governs rocket movement. Moving Listeria cells leave an evanescent trail of F-actin undergoing depolymerization at the distal end, the steady-state length of which is proportional to the speed of bacterial movement. This movement is random, so some bacteria eventually reach the cell periphery, come into contact with the membrane, and push it, leading to the formation of finger-like protrusions with a bacterium at the tip (Fig. 3F and G). These pseudopods penetrate uninfected neighboring cells and are in turn engulfed by phagocytosis, resulting in the formation of a secondary phagosome delimited by a double membrane (Fig. 3H), with the inner membrane originating from the donor cell (Fig. 3G). Bacteria escape rapidly (within 5 min) from the newly formed vacuole by dissolving its double membrane, reach the cytoplasm, and initiate a new round of intracellular proliferation and direct intercellular spread (117, 453, 549, 601, 652, 654-656) (Fig. 3A). In tissue culture, this infectious cycle is reflected in the formation of plaques in the cell monolayer (641, 672). Actin-based i